While powder eyeshadows are more common, cream eyeshadows are an easier, more straightforward alternative. Cream eyeshadows are considered much more manageable for beginners since they have this user-friendly foolproof formula. They are really easy to blend, and you can just do a wash of color in one shade, and your makeup look is complete.
Most people are hesitant to use cream products due to fear that they will crease, smudge, or slide off, especially if you are prone to oily lids. But when you discover just how easy they are to apply and how perfectly subtle they can look, you will get hooked.
The trick with cream eyeshadow is that you have to work quite quickly and blend them evenly for the best results, but on the other hand, if you come across that one formula that works best for you, there is no going back to the powders. They are perfect if you like a glossy, dewy eye look that will last for a long time. We have accumulated a list of the best long-lasting, crease-proof creme shadows, from luxury to affordable.
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour
This versatile cream stick delivers smooth application and buildable color with a shimmering pay-off that lasts up to 12 hours. The caviar sticks can be used both as an eyeshadow or as an eyeliner. You don’t need to rush to blend the product but once it is set, it will not budge. The texture is creamy but with great quality that does not crease. With 24 shades, you can find something for any makeup look you are in the mood for.
Maybelline Eye Studio Color Tattoo Eyeshadow
These cream eyeshadows deliver intense color payoff in metallic, shimmering, and matte finishes. In one easy swipe, the product seamlessly melts on the lids. You don't need to prime your lid because these shadows are really high pigmented. They're crease-proof and waterproof, so you don't have to worry about the color being transferred to your clothes. The colors are versatile for a soft day-time look that you can easily turn into a night-time glam. They stick on tight for a long time but at the same time, they are gentle on super-sensitive eyes.
Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow
These are some of the nicest cream glitter eyeshadows in the game. With these, you can create some absolutely stunning looks just by swiping on the lid. So easy to apply and have a gorgeous glitter look with minimal fallout. With its uniquely lightweight, water-infused texture, the sparkle you get is incredible. The applicator is flat and fluffy, ideal for eye shapes where shadows tend to move around the crease. These liquid eyeshadows are long-wearing with a variety of unique shades, perfect for special occasions, but also for a little bit of punch on a regular working day.
Julep Eyeshadow 101 Eyeshadow Stick
Enriched with nourishing Vitamin C and Vitamin E, this waterproof, crème-to-powder formula eyeshadow stick delivers huge color payoff. For best results, it is recommended to prime the smudger by applying the eyeshadow to the back of your hand and packing it onto the smudger before use. The color starts out light and you can build on it to make it darker, however, you do need to work fast as it sets quickly.
Revlon ColorStay Creme Eyeshadow
ColorStay Cream Eyeshadow gives you a blendable, luxurious color with no creasing. It comes with a built-in, mess-free application brush. It has a waterproof formula that makes the eye makeup last up to 24 hours. They are available in 12 vibrant shades with metallic, matte, pearl and satin finishes. It works best when used with a primer. If you are looking for a nude-colored cream eyeshadow to use as a base for powder eyeshadows with that natural dewy look of the shimmer, this one is for you. Definitely one of the best drugstore cream eyeshadows.
Colourpop Super Shock Shadow
The infamous super shock shadows are known for their unique texture. With just one swipe they deliver an amazing color payoff without creasing, fading or fallout. Colourpop offers a plethora of shades and finishes at such an affordable price. The more metallic shades have a “wet” feel, while the more ones have a firmer consistency. You can apply just one layer for a sheer look or you can build it up to be more metallic. These are definitely the best shimmer eyeshadows and the fact that they are cruelty is doesn’t hurt.
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow
These luxury soft-focus illuminating pigments smooth over lines and imperfections for a visibly more youthful finish. This cream shadow is highly pigmented, you will only need to use the smallest finger dab to cover your eyelid, and it will last all day and night. Their water-infused formula has a cooling effect on hard-working eyes and vitamin E that hydrates delicate eyelids. The color formulations and lasting power make them a good value, even if the price tag is on the higher end.
Jillian Dempsey Lid Tints
These easy-to-use tints blend seamlessly to create anything from a natural through to a night-on-the-town makeup look. They can be worn alone for a natural look or mixed with eyeshadow for a glossy dimension. There are eight shades to choose including neutral shimmering warm browns to clear eye glosses. The tints are formulated with nutrient-dense organic jojoba oil and shea butter, alongside hydrating marula oil for a fresh feel.
E.l.f Smudge Pot Cream Eyeshadow
This long-lasting shadow is boosted with Vitamin E to nourish and hydrate the delicate eye area. The smooth gel formula glides on perfectly which allows you to use the products as an eyeshadow or eyeliner! The color is so vibrant and pigmented, perfect for a quick and easy on-the-go sort of eye look when you don’t have much time on your hands. For the quality of this product, it comes at a really affordable price.
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil
Made with a blend of mineral oil and powder, the creamy Jumbo Eye Pencils glide on effortlessly without any pulling, tugging or fading. They come in a rainbow of vivid colors that can be applied to your water lines, inner corners, and entire eyelid. These shadows feature a creamy formula that glides on smoothly like silk, is easy to blend and does not crease or dry-out.
BareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow + Primer
This crease-free, long-lasting Eyeshadow + Primer can be worn alone as a natural-looking eye makeup, or used as a primer to create a smooth base for eyeshadow application. The neutralizing tones fix imperfections and discoloration while the brightening shades tackle the look of dull skin. The cream-to-powder formula is easy to apply and blend and the matte finish with slight shimmer imitates the look of skin.